Dieter Fensel, Brahmananda Sapkota, Jos de Bruijn, Emilia Cimpian, Cristina Feier, Michael Felderer, Juan Miguel Gomez, Martin Hepp, Rubén Lara, Adrian Mocan, Francisco Jose Martin-Recuerda Moyano, Matthew Moran, Eyal Oren, Livia Predoiu, Dumitru Roman, Michael Stollberg, Ioan Toma, Laurentiu Vasiliu

• New member joined - Brahmananda Sapkota (DERI Galway)

• WSMO Primer - no deliverable online - a decision will be taken when  Sinuhe will be here
• D3.2 doesn’t have a deadline in the activity sheet
  • The authors wanted to wait for a stable version of D2 - D3.2 deadline depends on D2
  • There is also a SEKT use case that maybe incorporated and also the WSMX use case (Armin) may be related with D3.2
  • D3.2 will be reopened and it will use D2v1.0
  • D3.2 will contain for the next version B2C use case, and will be ready in two weeks
  • Deadline: 04.10.2004
• WSMO-Full has to be deleted from the activity sheet (WSMO -Full to be incorporated in D2)
• D14 status: nothing happened recently
• D17 to be updated on the site (Titi)  - the slides are difficult to find
• D19.1 WSMO in DIP  to become final: update the activity sheet accordingly
• D2v1.0: WSMO Standard
  • Section 3.7
    • an instance may be an instance of multiple concepts
    • The current approach = db approach: instance is like a row in a table
    • A solution would be to repeat the instance definition (define it again)
    • This solution is not consistent with the conceptual model which says that an instance is an instance of a single concept
    • Insert a foot note that says that an instance can be an instance of several concepts
    • This doesn’t apply for relations - a relation instance is an instance of only one relation
    • In the paragraph: “ For each attribute defined for the concept this instance is assigned to there should be a corresponding attribute value”, should has to be replaced with could
    • The previous change has to be applied for relation too
    • AttributeValues and parameterValues are difficult to handle because of the nfp; remove the nfp from their definition
    • Add the parameter value definition
  • Section 7
    • use a different delimiters than blanks from URI - Eyal  and Michael have to decide and send the final decision to Titi
    • Discussion if the relation parameters could be named or unnamed - Eyal to send a short note to Titi
    • Discussion related to the usage of  ->, <-, <-> : Eyal suggests to use flora syntax, but the language will became more unreadable; re-discus about arrows when Holger will raise this issue again
  • Section 5
    • The definition of mediators is sometimes ambiguous – the term connect instead of link should be used; Ruben to make a proposal and send it to Holger or Titi
    • All the changes discussed to be implemented by Monday - the version 1.0 will be final
• The next version to be discussed on Wednesday
• Next Wednesday: BPMO (Business Process Management Ontology) presentation by Laurentiu