Participants: John Dieter Jos Emilia Cristina Sven Jacek Holger Adrian Matt Axel Titi BN Francois James Laurentiu Mick Martin Michael Charles WSDL-S discussion 3 important elements from WSDL2: type, operations and interface (mechanism to group operations). WSDL-S operations have actions. We don’t need constraints on the execution of the operations, only pre and post-conditions. Pre and post-conditions can be defined at the operation level, interface level or both of them. Discussion about ASM, what it is and in which deliverable it is described WSDL-S does not provide definitions about how the pre and post-conditions should look like, just a place-holder. D24.2 The problems with the structure were corrected Some more adjustments are currently made Jacek: 2 problems: 1. Section 2.3.2. mentions mapping rules for mapping the instances (XML to WSML) is created ad-hoc with the ontologies, but no algorithm is presented; a final version should contain this mappings, or the deliverable should specify that is incomplete in this regard. Response: The creation of the rule is not trivial, and their creation should not be explicitly described in this document; it is more an implementation detail. 2. Jacek dislikes the verbosity of the mappings -> for a simple example he obtained 7 different instances, by applying the mapping rules Response: the structural integrity of the schema needs to be maintained, and the mappings should work both ways. Conclusion – the discussion will go on by email External reviewer, then becomes final Dead-line: this Friday D29 Mention the MSL – the Mediator Specification Language -> related work All sections should have the same subsections (Related vs Underlying) Section 4 - include an example Emilia will give a presentation based on a paper sent around by Axel Delete the comment in red from page 6 Orchestration of goals: 3 steps: data mediator, GGMediator, WGMediator OOMediators Listing 1 – a bracket needs to be closed GGMediator First bullet 3.1 exiting -> existing A GGMediator express the logical difference between two goals 3.3.1 Come up with a simpler logical definition (make one paragraph from 3 pages) Also rewrite 3.3.2 with the modified formal definition. WGMediator 4.3.1 should not be subtitle Example included (in TOC) Small English errors WWMediator Rewrite the scope of WWMediatos Deadline: 28th of October Presentation: Information on Choreography & Orchestration in DIP (by Michael Stollberg)