WSMO Phone Conference
Date: 11-10-2006
----------------------------

Notes taken by: Omair


Attendees:
-----------
Dieter Fensel
John Domingue
Michael Kifer
Jos de Bruijn
Emilia Cimpian
Jacek Kopecký
Mick Kerrigan
James Scicluna
Omair Shafiq
Ioan Toma
Adrian Mocan


Deliverables:
========

D15.1 - Orchestration in WSMO
----------------------------------
- Barry to provide the next version of deliverable after the DIP review.
- Deadline to be updated for the deliverable D15.1


D2 - Web Service Modeling Ontology
---------------------------------------
- Editors of the deliverable were not present.
- John:
   - Annotations in the WSMO conceptual model is getting mixed-in from engineering point of view
   - for example, instead of having attribute hasAnnotation, there could be a class named "Annotation" with "hasAnnotation" attribute and every WSMO top level element could inherit it to have the attribute
- Mick:
   - NFPs could also be handeled in the same way to have a super class and WSMO top level classes could inherit from it to have the NFPs
- Dieter:
   - This should only be considered for Web Services, Goals, Mediators
- Dieter to sit down with D2 editors to make the final version


D28.4 - Non-functional properties in Web Services
----------------------------------------------------

Updates by Ioan:
   - Implemented comments received in previous telecon
   - section 3, NFP tasks and types were clearly separated
   - NFP types were moved to section 4
   - Updates in sub-section 4.2 and 4.3 based on comments from previous telecon
Dieter:
   - Page 6, reference to Dublin core is missing
Mike:
   - What is the purpose of the ontology in the appendix of the document
Ioan:
   - It is because, in order to define the logical expression we need some concepts, relation. This ontology can be used for that purpose
John:
   - The ontologies should be described in the main document
Dieter:
   - Include more details in Section 5 (Annotations)
   - Ontologies of NFPs in annex, should be described in natural language in Section 4
   - Deadline is Friday, next week (20th October 2006)
   - What does it imply for WSML ?
Ioan:
   - WSMO model was updatd and these updates should be reflected in WSML as well


Presentation by Jacek on "WS-Policy Specification & Working Group"
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Questions after presentation:

Dieter:
   - How WS-Policy is linked to WSMO ?
Jacek:
   - Policies could be seen as NFPs
   - This should be updated in D24.1 (section 3)
Dieter:
   - The update mentioned by Jacek should be done by 3rd November 2006.

======================================
Next WSMO Phone Conference on 25th October 2006.