wsmo logo

D3.3 v0.1 WSMO Use Case "Virtual Travel Agency"

WSMO Working Draft 19 November 2004

This version:
http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041119/
Latest version:
http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/
Previous version:
http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/200411105/
 
Editors:
Michael Stollberg
Rubén Lara
 
Authors:
Michael Stollberg
Holger Lausen
Rubén Lara
Uwe Keller
Michal Zaremba
Armin Haller
Dieter Fensel
Michael Kifer
 
Reviewer:
Jos de Bruijn

This document is also available in non-normative PDF version.
Copyright © 2004 DERI®, All Rights Reserved. DERI liability, trademark, document use, and software licensing rules apply.


Abstract

This document specifies a concrete use case for modeling Semantic Web Services with the Web Service Modeling Ontology WSMO in the domain of e-tourism. A Virtual Travel Agency sells tickets for international train tickets, and a customer defines a Goal for purchasing such a ticket. This use case has been the initial WSMO Use Case defined in previous versions of the WSMO D3.2 Deliverable - WSMO Use Case and Testing. The main focus of this document is the concrete modeling of the top WSMO components, resulting in the specification of WSML, and to test and elaborate the approach and technologies for Web Service Discovery in WSMO.

For use case modeling, we stick to the final working draft of Web Service Modeling Ontology WSMO, Version 1.0, 20 September 2004 [Roman et al., 2004].

Related Documents

WSMO Standard: D2 v1.0 Web Service Modeling Ontology (WSMO), last version at: http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d2/

WSMO Primer: D3.1 v0.1 WSMO Primer

Web Service Modeling Language WSML: D16 v0.2 WSMO The WSML Family of Representation Languages

WSMO Discovery: D5.1 v0.1 WSMO Discovery


Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. Use Case Overview
2.1 Description
2.2 Scope
2.3 Actors, Roles and Goals
2.4 Usage Scenarios
2.5 System Architecture
3. WSMO Use Case Modeling
3.1 Ontologies
   3.1.1 International Train Ticket Ontology
   3.1.2 Date and Time Ontology
   3.1.3 Purchase Ontology
   3.1.4 Location Ontology
   3.1.5 VTA Use Case Knowledge Base
3.2 Goals
3.3 Web Services
3.4 Mediators
   3.4.1 OO Mediators
    3.4.2 WG Mediators
    3.4.3 GG Mediators
    3.4.4 WW Mediators
4. Web Service Discovery within WSMO
5. Conclusions and Future Work
References
Acknowledgements
 
Appendix A: Change Tracking
Appendix B: Related Resources
B.1 Used Ontologies in OWL
B.2 Related Ontologies

1. Introduction

This use case is defined in the domain of e-tourism: a Virtual Travel Agency sells tickets for international train tickets, and a customer defines a Goal for purchasing such a ticket. Using the conceptual framework of WSMO we specify the top-level notions of Ontologies, Goals, Web Services and Mediators for this use case.

A Web Service of a Virtual Travel Agency, short: VTA, offers end-user services for searching and buying train tickets for itineraries in Austria and in Germany. This Web Service is composed out of other Web Services, namely one for searching existing train connections, and one for purchasing train tickets online. As a user request we assume that the user wants to purchase an international train ticket. The course of the use case shall be the following:

This document is structured as follows: Section 2 gives and overview of the use case, describing the overall setting for of the use case and identifying the technical challenges arising for Semantic Web Service technologies; Section 3 defines the needed WSMO components and provides the WSML models for the distinct WSMO components of the use case along with explanations of the design and modeling decisions; Section 4 explains the WSMO Discovery as realized within this use case; finally, Section 5 concludes the use case. Appendix A provides a change tracking to previous version of the document; Appendix B provides related resources for this use case.

 

2. Use Case Overview

According to the general framework for defining use cases for WSMO defined in WSMO Use Case Overview document, section 2, this section provides a description of the setting of this use case. In [He et al., 2004], the travel agency use case is separated into two use cases - one with static discovery and one with automated discovery. With Semantic Web Services we clearly want to support automated discovery.

2.1 Description

Imagine a “Virtual Traveling Agency”, called VTA for short, which is an end user service providing eTourism services to customers. These services can cover all kinds of information services concerned with tourism information - from information about events and sights in an area to services that support booking of flights, hotels, rental cars, etc. online. Such VTAs are already existent, currently those portals are accessible via html sites. The partners of the VTA are integrated via conventional B2B integration. By applying Semantic Web Services, a VTA will be more easily be able to configure an invoke Web Services provided by several eTourism suppliers and aggregate them into new customer services. Such VTAs providing automated eTourism services to end users via different interfaces and can be more easily reconfigured according to the actual needs..

Our VTA use case that aggregates Web Services of different tourism service providers. In a nutshell shall it provides the following functionality: A customer uses the VTA service as the entry point for his requests. These end-user services are aggregated by the VTA by invoking and combining Web Services offered by several tourism service providers. To facilitate this, there can be a so called "umbrella" contract between the service providers and the VTA for regulating usage and allowance of the Web Services. Figure 2 gives an overview (modified and extended from W3C Travel Agent Use Case overview, as defined in [He et al., 2004]).

VTA Architecture
Figure 2. Use Case Overview: Virtual Travel Agency based on Semantic Web Services

2.2 Scope

The scenario outlines a general structure for VTAs that can be extended to more complex scenarios wherein the customer can be a Web Service itself, thus creating a network of composed services that offer complex tourism services. For example, one VTA can provide flight booking services for an airline union, another VTA aggregates booking service for a worldwide hotel chain, and a third VTA provides booking services for rental cars by combining the services of several worldwide operating car rental agencies. Then, another VTA uses these services for providing an end-user service for booking complete holiday trips worldwide.

2.3 Actors, Roles and Goals

In the general use case there are 3 actors. The following defines why they participate in this use case (goal) and the particular interactions they are involved in (roles).

  1. Customer: the end-user that requests a service provided by the VTA
      - Goal: automated resolution of the request by a user-friendly tourism service
      - Role: end-user, interacts with VTA for service usage, payment, and non-computational assets (e.g. receiving the actual ticket when booking a trip)
  2. Tourism Service Providers: commercial companies that provides specific tourism services
      - Goal: sell service to end customers, maximize profit as a commercial company
      - Role: provides tourism service as a Web Service (also provides the necessary semantic descriptions of the Web Services), may have a usage and allowance contract with the VTA
  3. VTA: the intermediate between the Customer and the Tourism Service Providers. It provides tourism services to customers by aggregating the separate services provided by the single Service Providers.
      - Goal: provide high-quality end-user tourism services, uses existing tourism services and aggregates these into new services, maximize profit as a commercial company / represent union of service providers (depending on the owners of the VTA).
      - Role: interacting with customer via user interface (can be web-based for direct human customers interaction or via Web Services for machine-users), usage and allowance contract for Web Services offered by Service Providers, centrally holding all functionalities for handling Semantic Web Services (mechanisms for discovery, composition, execution, etc.)

2.4 Usage Scenarios

We identify the following usage scenarios

  1. VTA interacts with Service Providers on contract and Web Service usage and allowance
    - Participating Actors: VTA and Service Providers
    - Activities: business contract negotiation
    - Technological Requirements: contract information requirements are modeled in the system, i.e. Web Service usage is implemented via Policies
    - Possible Extensions: contract negotiation can be supported by automated mechanisms
  2. Customer requests VTA for searching tourism service offers, VTA detects and queries suitable Web Services and forwards results to Customer
    - Participating Actors: Customer, VTA, Tourism Service Providers
    - Activities:
       (1) Customer selects "Search" services as provided by the VTA
       (2) VTA discovers, invokes and executes corresponding Web Services
    - Technological Requirements:
       (1) VTA has to pre-define the "Search" functionality that can be requested by a Customer
       (2) the Tourism Service Providers' Web Services must be semantically described in order to support dynamic discovery (assuming that single Web Services can perform the search functionality)
       (3) VTA has to provide mechanisms for automated Service Discovery
    - Possible Extensions:
  3. Customer selects a concrete offer and requests booking for this offer (interacting with the VTA),VTA detects and aggregates Web Services for booking (incl. booking, payment, etc.), displays result to Customer and handles complete execution of customer-interaction (computational part)
    - Participating Actors: Customer, VTA, Tourism Service Providers
    - Activities:
       (1) Customer selects one concrete offer out of the Search results of usage scenario 2
       (2) VTA discovers and composes available Web Services from Service Providers and composes them into the functionality to satisfy the user request
       (3) VTA executes the Web Services in the sequence determined, controls the execution (handles errors and detects alternative paths if a Web Service fails)
       (4) VTA interacts with Customer during execution when further information is needed (e.g. a credit card number for payment)
    - Technological Requirements: contract information information requirements are modeled in the system, i.e. Web Service usage is implemented via Policies
       (1) Web Services must be semantically described in order to support dynamic discovery, composition, and execution
       (2) VTA has to hold mechanisms for automated Service Discovery, Composition, and Execution
       (3) VTA has to provide and interaction interface for contingent Customer-interaction during Service execution
    - Possible Extensions: advanced mechanisms for automated execution of aggregated Web Services
  4. VTA interacts with Customer and Service Provider for non-computational parts (e.g. delivery of actual tickets)
    - Participating Actors: Customer, VTA, Tourism Service Providers
    - Activities: customer notification, accounting, good delivery (out of computational system), etc.
    - Technological Requirements: mechanisms for notification and accounting
    - Possible Extensions: Web Services can be used for:

2.5 System Architecture

In this use case, the VTA is the central point of interaction between the Customer and other Web Services. Regarding the technological requirements, it is obvious from the usage scenario descriptions that (1) the Web Services offered by the Service Providers have to carry sufficient descriptive information to support automated Web Service usage, and (2) that the VTA has to provide all mechanisms to handle Semantic Web Services. The basic architecture of such a VTA as a central entity for Semantic Web Services handling is shown in Figure 3. The essential functionalities of Semantic Web Service enabled VTAs – with special regard to the requirements for Semantic Web Service technologies – are:

VTA Architecture
Figure 3. General Architecture of a SWS-enabled VTA

Summarizing, the VTA is a SWS-enabled B2C application that provides an end-user service following a client/server model. In order to support coherent functionality of the VTA and to ensure that the descriptions of Web Services are compatible to this, an overall framework for SWS technologies is needed. This is provided by WSMO.

Semantic Web Service technology can be applied to ease the described use case (a) for the customer (to find the VTA and resolve his goal) and (b) for the VTA that benefits from semantic description of its business partners. These ease the combination and rearrangement of existing services for the VTA and allows him to flexibly offer new services. In case composition and discovery have reached a higher level of maturity it can even be thought that the technologies (in this case discovery and composition) can be used directly by the end user. So that he himself combines the travel services offered, thus not using the extra intermediate party (the VTA).

3. WSMO Use Case Modeling

This section exemplifies the specification of this use case within the Web Service Modeling Ontology WSMO. The provided listings use the conceptual model and syntax presented in WSMO, final version 1.0 [Roman et al., 2004]. The listings provide have been validated with the WSML Online Validation Service.

The subsequent sections provide the modeling of the resources along with detailed explanations on modeling decisions and related issues. The following tables provide an overview of the resources specified in this use case.

Table 1. "International Train Ticket Ontology"
WSMO component type ontology
name International Train Ticket Ontology
description defines ontology constructs for the domain of international train connections
imported ontologies /
used mediators
- Date and Time Ontology
- Location Ontology
- OWL Person Mediator
- OWL Fact Book Mediator
main constructs main concepts:
station, itinerary, ticket, trip, traintrip
 
axioms:
stationCountry, departureBeforeArrival, startNotEqualEnd
WSML model Listing 1

 

Table 2. "Date and Time Ontology"
WSMO component type ontology
name Date and Time Ontology
description defines notions of date and time, and general interdependencies between them
imported ontologies /
used mediators
none
main constructs main concepts:
instant, interval, date, time, dateandtime
 
functions:
julianDayNumber, daysBetween, secondsBetween, secondsFromMidnight
 
relations:
contains (for intervals)
 
axioms:
equality / before / after / between for date and time notions, integrity contraints
WSML model Listing 2

 

Table 3. "Purchase Ontology"
WSMO component type ontology
name Purchase Ontology
description defines notions of purchasing, incl. buyer, seller, purchase oder, purchase partners, payment notions, etc.; based on RosettaNet , but adopted for B2C setting
imported ontologies /
used mediators
- Date an Time Ontology
- OWL Currency Mediator
main constructs main concepts:
purchase, buyer, seller, contactInformation, purchaseOrder, product, paymentMethod, paymentTerms, delivery
WSML model Listing 3

 

Table 4. "Location Ontology"
WSMO component type ontology
name Location Ontology
description defines geographical notions and postal address;
extends / combines existing domain ontologies
imported ontologies /
used mediators
- OWL Fact Book Mediator
- OWL Address Mediator
- OWL Geo Mediator
main constructs main concepts:
country, address, city, state, border, distance;
incl. concepts / attributes imported via mediators
 
functions:
distanceInKilometers, distanceInMiles,
 
relations:
equalDistance, lessThanDistance, moreThanDistance
 
axioms:
integrity contraints
WSML model Listing 4

 

Table 5. "VTA Use Case Knowledge Base"
WSMO component type ontology
name VTA Use Case Knowledge Base
description holds all pre-defined instance data needed within the use case
imported ontologies /
used mediators
- Train Connection Ontology
- Purchase Ontology
- Date and Time Ontology
- Location Ontology
main constructs instances for :
stations, currentDate, credit card types, locations (continents, countries, states, cities), drop ship carriers, transportations means
WSML model Listing 45

 

Table 6. "General Goal for buying a ticket online "
WSMO component type goal
name Buying a train ticket online
description defines the general ontological structure of goal notions for buying tickets online according to the ontologies; this goal serves as a template for concrete goals (see table 6).
imported ontologies /
used mediators
- Train Connection Ontology
- Purchase Ontology
- Location Ontology
main constructs postcondition:
purchase a ticket for an itinerary (a trip and a passenger)
 
effect:
get the purchased ticket delivered to the buyer
WSML model Listing 6

 

Table 7. "Concrete Goal for buying a ticket online "
WSMO component type goal
name Buying a train ticket from Innsbruck to Frankfurt
description Buying a train ticket online for an itinerary from Innsbruck to Frankfurt for a specific passenger with payment by credit card
This goal is derived by specializing og the general goal (table 5) via an GG Mediator (table 12)
imported ontologies /
used mediators
- Date and Time
- GG Mediator 1
main constructs postcondition:
purchase a ticket for an itinerary for a trip from Innsbruck to Frankfurt on 17th July 2004 for Tim Berners Lee, departure between 6 and 7 p.m.
 
effect:
get the purchased ticket delivered to the buyer
WSML model Listing 7

 

Table 8. "ÖBB Web Service for selling international train tickets online "
WSMO component type web service
name OEBB Online Ticket Booking Web Service
description web service for booking online train tickets for Austria and Germany, offered by the ÖBB (Austrian national train operator)
imported ontologies /
used mediators
- Train Connection Ontology
- Purchase Ontology
- Date and Time Ontology
- Location Ontology
main constructs precondition:
a buyer, and information on the trip that a ticket is searched and sold for and the passenger for whom the ticket shall be valid
 
assumption:
if the payment method is credit card, then the credit card has to be valid (i.e. not expired)
 
postcondition:
a purchase for a ticket by ÖBB as provider, for itineraries valid for a train trip with start- and endloction in Austria or Germany and for a passenger, incl. price, and payment only via credit card
 
effect:
delivery of sold ticket by drop ship carrier or by online delivery
WSML model Listing 8

 

Table 9. "OWL Address Mediator"
WSMO component type oo mediator
name importing the OWL Factbook ontology to WSML
description Mediator to import an OWL address ontology into a WSML locations ontology
imported ontologies /
used mediators
 
main constructs source component: an Address Ontology in OWL
target component: Location Ontology (Table 4)
mediation service: not specified
WSML model Listing 9

 

Table 10. "OWL Currency Mediator"
WSMO component type oo mediator
name importing the OWL Currency ontology to WSML
description Mediator to import an OWL currency ontology into a WSML purchase order ontology
imported ontologies /
used mediators
 
main constructs source component: an Currency Ontology in OWL
target component: Purchase Ontology (Table 3)
mediation service: not specified
WSML model Listing 10

 

Table 11. "OWL Factbook Mediator"
WSMO component type oo mediator
name importing the OWL Factbook ontology to WSML
description Mediator to import an OWL factbook ontology into a WSML ontology
imported ontologies /
used mediators
 
main constructs source component: the OWL Factbook (in OWL)
target component: Location Ontology (Table 4)
mediation service: not specified
WSML model Listing 11

 

Table 12. "OWL Person Mediator"
WSMO component type oo mediator
name importing the OWL Person ontology to WSML
description Mediator to import an OWL person ontology into a WSML ontology
imported ontologies /
used mediators
 
main contructs source component: a Person ontology (in OWL)
target component: Internaction Train Connection Ontology (Table 1)
mediation service: not specified
WSML model Listing 12

 

Table 13. "GG Mediator"
WSMO component type gg mediator
name GG Mediator that that links the general Goal for buying tickets with the concrete Goal for buying a train ticket from Innsbruck to Frankfurt
description Restricts the trip to train trips within Austria and Germany
imported ontologies /
used mediators
all ontologies and mediators are inherited from the source component; no additional ontologies or OO Mediators are needed
main constructs source component: general goal for buying tickets (Table 5)
target component: concrete Goal for buying a train ticket (Table 6)
mediation service: not specified
WSML model Listing 13

 

3.1 Ontologies

With regard to modularized ontologies as a basic design principle of WSMO, we define four separate domain ontologies as the the terminology definitions for the use case:

  1. "International Train Ticket" describes the domain of train tickets
  2. "Date and Time" defines a general model for specifying time and dates and relationships of them
  3. "Purchase" describes generic elements of purchasing a product between a buyer and a seller.
  4. "Locations" describes locations (such as continents, countries and cities and their interrelation).

The ontologies specified in the following are intended to be "real ontologies" in the sense that they describe the specific domain as a shared conceptualization in a sufficient manner. This allows to reuse this ontologies in different settings and use cases - for example, notions or date and time or a general purchase ontology are needed in a lot of other possible scenarios. However, we do not claim the defined below to be such generic ontologies, but they will be enhanced and completed within cooperations with other use cases, projects, and initiatives. Appendix B provides the original ontologies that are used within the domain ontologies specified in this section.

At this point in time, WSMO does not provide a technique to link to large set of instances. Therefore, in this version of the ontology we only include some example instances, which holds for the other ontologies defined in this use case as well. For reader's convenience, the relevant instances for this use case are gathererd in the VTA Use Case Knowlege Base, a separate ontology. The inclusion of links to large set of instances will be considered in future versions of WSMO.

3.1.1 International Train Ticket Ontology

The "International Train Ticket" Ontology defines a train trip and the surrounding concepts as defined the WSML definition of the ontology shown in Listing 1.

The definition of the ontology is based on the travel itinerary ontology from the DAML ontology library, which is also available in Appendix B6 in OWL abstract syntax. The ontology defines travel itineraries for trips by plane. Our ontology reuses the itinerary and flight concepts and adapt them to define train trips, also introducing new concepts such as train station. The international train ticket ontology also makes use of the person ontology defined at http://daml.umbc.edu/ontologies/ittalks/person (Appendix B1), which defines a subset of vCard. The person concept is used to define the passenger information for an itinerary. We did not find any other available ontologies that model the domain of train tickets or itineraries. The first version of the harmonize ontology for the tourism domain focuses on the events and accommodations subdomains. We will take into account future versions of the harmonise ontology, as they are likely to include the travelling subdomain.

Listing 1. Domain Ontology “International Train Ticket”
namespace <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/trainConnection#>>
      dc:<<http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1#>>
      dt:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/dateTime#>>
      prs:<<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/owlPersonMediator.wsml>>
      loc:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location#>>
      geo:<<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/owlGeoMediator.wsml#>>
      xsd:<<http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#>>

ontology <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/trainConnection>>

      nonFunctionalProperties
            dc:title hasValue "International Train Connections Ontology"
            dc:creator hasValue "DERI International"
            dc:subject hasValues {"Train", "Itinerary", "Train Connection", "Ticket"}
            dc:description hasValue "International Train Connections"
            dc:publisher hasValue "DERI International"
            dc:contributor hasValues {"Michael Stollberg",
                  <<http://homepage.uibk.ac.at/~C703225/foaf.rdf>>,
                  <<http://homepage.uibk.ac.at/~c703240/foaf.rdf>>,
                  <<http://homepage.uibk.ac.at/~c703262/foaf.rdf>>}
            dc:date hasValue "2004-10-08"
            dc:type hasValue <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d2#ontologies>>
            dc:format hasValue "text/html"
            dc:identifier hasValue <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/trainConnection>>
            dc:source hasValue <<http://www.daml.org/2001/06/itinerary/itinerary-ont>>
            dc:language hasValue "en-US"
            dc:relation hasValues {<<http://www.daml.org/2001/06/itinerary/itinerary-ont>>,
                  <<http://daml.umbc.edu/ontologies/ittalks/person>>,
                  <<http:://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/dateTime>>,
                  <<http:://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location>>,
                  <<http://www.daml.org/2001/02/geofile/geofile-ont>>,
                  <<http://www.daml.org/2001/02/geofile/geofile-ont>>}
            dc:coverage hasValue "ID:7029392 Name:World"
            dc:rights hasValue <<http://www.deri.org/privacy.html>>
            version hasValue "$Revision: 1.6 $"
      endNonFunctionalProperties

      importedOntologies {<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/dateTime>>,
            <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location>>}

      usedMediators {<<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/owlPersonMediator.wsml>>,
            <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/owlFactBookMediator.wsml>>}
            
 
      concept station subConceptOf geo:geographicLocation
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "Train station"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            code ofType xsd:string
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "Code of the station"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
            borderToCountry ofType loc:border
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "For stations located at the border"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
      
      concept ticket 
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "a ticket for an itinerary"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            itinerary ofType itinerary
            provider ofType po:partnerDescription
            price ofType po:price 

      concept itinerary
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "An itinerary between two locations"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            passenger ofType prs:person
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "prs:person is a subset of vCard (http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2425.txt)"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
            recordLocatorNumber ofType xsd:string
            trip ofType trip
            
      concept trip
            start ofType loc:location
            end ofType loc:location
            via ofType set loc:location
            departure ofType dt:dateAndTime
            arrival ofType dt:dateAndTime
            duration ofType dt:interval
            distance ofType loc:distance 
            
      concept trainTrip subConceptOf trip
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "A train trip"       
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            start ofType station
            end ofType station
            via ofType set station
            seat ofType xsd:string
            train ofType xsd:string
            class ofType xsd:string

      axiom stationCountry
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "Integrity constraint: if a station is located in a place
                        which is located in a given country, the country of the station is the
                        same"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            definedBy
                  constraint
                        ?S[
                              locatedIn hasValue ?L,
                              country hasValue ?C
                        ]memberOf station
                        and not ?L[
                              country hasValue ?C
                        ]memberOf loc:location .

      axiom departureBeforeArrival
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "Integrity Constraint: departure has to be before arrival"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            definedBy
             constraint
                   ?T[
                         departure hasValue ?D,
                         arrival hasValue ?A
                   ]memberOf trip
                   and ?A <= ?D.

      axiom startNotEqualEnd
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "Integrity Constraint: the start and end of a trip have to be different"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            definedBy
             constraint
                   ?T[
                         start hasValue ?Start,
                         end hasValue ?End
                   ]memberOf trip 
                   and ?Start = ?End.
            

3.1.2 Date and Time Ontology

The "Date and Time Ontology" in Listing 2 defines models for dates (i.e. certain days) and time (i.e. definition of certain points in time). Further, it defines axioms that represent conventional aspects of date and time, like ´before´ and ´after´, etc. In the use case, this is needed to determine validity of train connections, e.g for ensuring that a ticket is not for an itinerary that is in the past. It also can be used generally for expressing dates and time and relationships between them.

The main ontology taken into consideration for developing this conceptual model of Date and Time is an entry sub-ontology of time, available at http://www.isi.edu/~pan/damltime/time-entry.owl. This ontology uses abstract temporal concepts like instant, interval and event and uses the Gregorian calendar as representation (partly using own encoding and partly using XSD encoding). Axioms are defined in first order logic in the accompanying paper [Pan and Hobbs]; there also is a LISP version of these axioms available at http://www.cs.rochester.edu/~ferguson/daml/daml-time-20030728.lisp. Other ontologies like COBRA calenderclock ontology (http://daml.umbc.edu/ontologies/cobra/0.4/calendarclock) are only a straight forward representation of the Gregorian calendar, without any abstraction of concepts and description of axioms. Widely used concrete representations for date and time are defined in ISO 8601 (Numeric representation of Dates and Time) and in the XML Schema Definition (http://www.w3.org/TR/xmlschema-2/), which is based on ISO 8601. In a later stage when it is clear which build in predicates can be used we will add a syntactical mapping to xsd:dateTime.

Listing 2. Domain Ontology “Date and Time”
namespace
      dc: <<http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1#>>
      targetNameSpace: <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/dateTime#>>

ontology <<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/dateTime/>>

      nonFunctionalProperties
            dc:title hasValue "Date and Time Ontology"
            dc:creator hasValue "DERI International"
            dc:subject hasValues {"Date", "Time", "Date and Time Algebra"}
            dc:description hasValue "generic representation of data and time including basic algebra"
            dc:publisher hasValue "DERI International"
            dc:date hasValue "2004-10-04"
            dc:type hasValue <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d2/v1.0/#ontologies>>
            dc:format hasValue "text/html"
            dc:language hasValue "en-US"
            dc:relation hasValues {<<http://www.isi.edu/~pan/damltime/time-entry.owl>>,
                  <<http://www.w3.org/TR/xmlschema-2/>>}
            dc:coverage hasValue "World"
            dc:rights hasValue <<http://www.deri.org/privacy.html>>
            version hasValue "$Revision: 1.2 $"
      endNonFunctionalProperties

      comment: conceptDefinitions
            concept instant
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "An instant represents a particular point in time and is the super concept
                              of all concrete representations such as the Gregorian calendar"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties

            concept interval
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "An interval represents a duration between 2 points in time"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  start ofType instant
                  end ofType instant

            concept date subConceptOf instant
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "concept date and its representation according to the Gregorian Calendar"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  dayOfMonth ofType dayOfMonth
                  monthOfYear ofType monthOfYear
                  year ofType year

            concept dayOfMonth subConceptOf xsd:integer
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "day of a month is represented by an integer"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties

            concept year subConceptOf xsd:integer
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "year is represented by an integer"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties

            concept monthOfYear subConceptOf xsd:integer
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "monthOfYear is represented by an integer"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties

            concept time
                  hourOfDay ofType hourOfDay
                  minuteOfHour ofType minuteOfHour
                  secondOfMinute ofType secondOfMinute

            concept secondOfMinute subConceptOf xsd:integer
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "a secondOfMinute is represented by an integer"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties

            concept minuteOfHour subConceptOf xsd:integer
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "a minuteOfHour is represented by an integer"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties

            concept hourOfDay subConceptOf xsd:integer
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "a hourOfDay is represented by an integer"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties

            concept dateAndTime subConceptOf instant
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "concept date and time and representing together a specific point of time (instant)"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  date ofType date
                  time ofType time

      comment: functionDefintions
            function julianDayNumber
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "The Julian Day Count is a uniform count of days from a remote epoch
                              in the past (about 4712 BC). At this instant, the Julian Day Number is 0. Once
                              you have the Julian Day Number of a particular date in history, it is easy to
                              calculate time elapsed between it and any other Julian Day Number"
                        dc:source hasValue <<http://quasar.as.utexas.edu/BillInfo/JulianDatesG.html>>
                              dc:description hasValue "For each instant there should exist a corresponding Julian Day
                                    Number, however it may not be always defined only by this binary predicate,
                                    e.g. if the instant is represented as Gregorian Date and it is a date between
                                    1582 and 1924 a country      must be given as third parameter (since e.g. Greece
                                    changed no earlier then 9th of March 1924 from the Julian to the Gregorian Calendar)"
                              comment: The following dc:source indicates which country changed in which year
                              comment: from the Julian to the Gregorian Calendar
                              dc:source hasValue <<http://members.brabant.chello.nl/~h.reints/cal/whenjul2greg.htm>>
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  instant ofType instant
                  range ofType xsd:integer

            function daysBetween
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "(Instant1, Instant2, Difference) is a triple of the ternary relation
                              corresponding to this function iff Instant1 and Instant2 are members of the concept
                              instant (particular point in time) and Instant2 is Difference days after Instant1."
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  instant1 ofType instant
                  instant2 ofType instant
                  range ofType xsd:integer

            function secondsBetween
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "(Instant1, Instant2, Difference) is a triple of the ternary relation
                              corresponding to this function      iff Instant1 and Instant2 are members of the concept
                              instant (particular point in time) and Instant2 is Differnce seconds after Instant1."
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  instant1 ofType instant
                  instant2 ofType instant
                  range ofType xsd:integer

            function secondsFromMidnight
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "(Time, SecondsFromMidnight) is a tuple of the binary relation
                              corresponding to this function iff SecondsFromMidnight are the seconds elapsed from
                              00:00:00 of the same day.
                              This simplifies the axiomatization of the difference between two given times"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  time ofType time
                  range ofType xsd:integer

      comment: relationDefintions
            relation contains
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "(Interval, X) is a tuple of the binary relation
                              corresponding to this function iff Interval contains X and X is an instant or an
                              interval"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  interval ofType interval
                  intervalOrInstant ofType instantOrInterVal

      concept instantOrInterVal
            definedBy
                  forAll ?x (?x memberOf instantOrInterVal <-> ?x memberOf instant or ?x memberOf interval).

      comment: axiomDefinitions
            axiom invalidMonthOfYear
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "integrity constraint for valid monthOfYear"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                  constraint
                        ?X memberOf monthOfYear and
                        (?X < 1 or X > 12).

            axiom invalidDayOfMonth
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "integrity constraint for valid dayOfMonths"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                  constraint
                              ?X memberOf dayOfMonth and
                              (X < 1 or X > 31).

            axiom validDate
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "Integrity Constraints for date.
                              The dayOfMonth is valid in dependency of the actual monthOfYear, in a leap
                              year the month 2 of the Year has 29 days otherwise 28. For leap years holds
                              the following:      Every year divisible by 4 is a leap year.      However, every
                              year divisible by 100 is not a leap year. However, every year divisible by
                              400 is a leap year after all.

                              Note: This axiomatization is still imprecise, since the country plays a role
                              when defining a valid day of the month: E.g. 1712 was a double leap year
                              in Sweden, i.e. February 1712 had 30 days in Sweden.

                              The mathematical function symbol modulo is assumed to be defined elsewhere
                              as that it returns the remainder after an integer division of its
                              first argument by its second"
                        dc:source hasValue <<http://www.tondering.dk/claus/cal/node3.html>>
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                  constraint
                              ?X memberOf date and (
                               (?X.dayOfMonth > 28 and ?X.monthOfYear = 2 and
                                     not ((modulo(?X.year ,4) = 0 and not modulo(?X.year ,100) = 0)
                                                      or modulo(?X.year ,400) = 0))
                                    or (?X.dayOfMonth > 29 and ?X.monthOfYear = 2)
                                    or (?X.dayOfMonth > 30 and ?X.monthOfYear = 4)
                                    or (?X.dayOfMonth > 30 and ?X.monthOfYear = 6)
                                    or (?X.dayOfMonth > 30 and ?X.monthOfYear = 9)
                                    or (?X.dayOfMonth > 30 and ?X.monthOfYear = 11)).


            axiom invalidHourOfDay
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "integrity constraint for valid hourOfDay:"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                  constraint
                              ?X memberOf hourOfDay and
                              (?X < 0 or ?X >= 24).

            axiom invalidMinuteOfHour
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "integrity constraint for valid minuteOfHour:"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                  constraint
                              ?X memberOf minuteOfHour and
                              (?X < 0 or ?X >= 60).

            axiom invalidSecondOfMinute
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "integrity constraint for valid secondOfMinute:"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                  constraint
                              ?X memberOf secondOfMinute and
                              (?X < 0 or ?X >= 60).

            axiom invalidInterval
                  definedBy
                  constraint
                              ?X memberOf interval and ?X.start >= ?X.end.

            axiom equalityDate
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "computes equality of a date"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        X = ?Y <-
                              ?Y memberOf date and ?X memberOf date and
                              ?X.dayOfMonth = ?Y.dayOfMonth and
                              ?X.monthOfYear = ?Y.monthOfYear and
                              ?X.year = ?Y.year.

            axiom beforeDate
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "computes if a given date X is before another date ?Y"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        ?X < ?Y <-
                              ?Y memberOf date and ?X memberOf date and
                              ((?X.dayOfMonth = ?Y.dayOfMonth and ?X.monthOfYear = ?Y.monthOfYear and ?X.year = ?Y.year) or
                              (?X.monthOfYear < ?Y.monthOfYear and ?X.year = ?Y.year) or
                              (?X.year < ?Y.year)).

            axiom afterDate
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "defined as inverse of beforeDate"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        ?X > ?Y <- ?Y < ?X.

            axiom julianDayNumber
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "This Axiom describes how the correct Julian Day Number
                              can be computed for a given Gregorian Calendar Date. Note
                              that the Gregorian Calendar was introduced in 15.October 1582.
                              however until 1919 this axiomatization is not unambiguous since the country
                              should be taken into to account as 3rd parameter (e.g. Greece
                              changed at the 9 Mar 1924 from the Julian to the Gregorian calendar).

                              Details to the axiomatization
                              If the month is January or February we subtract 1 from the year to get a new Year
                              and add 12 to the month to get a new Month. (Thus, we are thinking of January and
                              February as being the 13th and 14th month of the previous year and March is the
                              start of the year, this simplifies the calculation considering the leap year)

                              Within the calculation the fractional part of all results has to be dropped,
                              here we use the function symbol floor() [it can be rewritten as predicate,
                              however it gets less readable]

                              A more lengthy description of this axiomatization can be found at
                              http://quasar.as.utexas.edu/BillInfo/JulianDatesG.html"

                        dc:source hasValues {<<http://quasar.as.utexas.edu/BillInfo/JulianDatesG.html>>,
                              <<http://members.brabant.chello.nl/~h.reints/cal/whenjul2greg.htm>>}
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                        definedBy
                              julianDayNumber[instant hasValue ?X, result hasValue ?JDN]
                              <-
                              ?X memberOf date and
                              ((
                                          ?X.monthOfYear < 3 and
                                          ?Y = ?X.year -1 and
                                          ?M = ?X.monthOfYear + 12
                                    )
                                    or
                                    (
                                          ?X.monthOfYear > 2 and
                                          ?Y = ?X.year and
                                          M = ?X.monthOfYear
                              ))
                              and
                              ?D = ?X.dayOfMonth and
                              ?A = floor(?Y / 100) and
                              ?B = floor(?A / 4) and
                              ?C = 2 - ?A + ?B and
                              ?E = floor(365.25 * (?Y + 4716)) and
                              ?F = floor(30.6001 * (?M + 1)) and
                              ?JDN = ?C + ?D + ?E + ?F - 1524.


            axiom daysBetweenDates
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "the difference in days between 2 dates"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        daysBetween[instant1 hasValue ?D1, instant2 hasValue ?D2, result hasValue ?X] <-
                              ?D1 memberOf date and ?D2 memberOf date and
                              ?X = julianDayNumber(?D1) - julianDayNumber(?D2).

            axiom equalityTime
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "computes if two given times are the same"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        ?X = ?Y <-
                              ?X memberOf time and ?Y memberOf time and
                              ?X.secondOfMinute = ?Y.secondOfMinute and
                              ?X.minuteOfHour = ?Y.minuteOfHour and
                              ?X.hourOfDay = ?Y.hourOfDay.

            axiom beforeTime
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "computes if a given time ?X is before another time ?Y"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                   ?X < ?Y <-
                              ?X memberOf time and ?Y memberOf time and
                              ((?X.secondOfMinute < ?Y.secondOfMinute and ?X.minuteOfHour = ?Y.minuteOfHour and ?X.hourOfDay = ?Y.hourOfDay) or
                              (?X.minuteOfHour < ?Y.minuteOfHour and ?X.hourOfDay = ?Y.hourOfDay) or
                              (?X.hourOfDay < ?Y.hourOfDay)).

            axiom afterTime
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "defined as inverse of beforeTime"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        ?X > ?Y <- ?Y < ?X.

            axiom secondsFromMidnight
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "computes the amount of seconds from midnight"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        secondsFromMidnight[time hasValue ?T, result hasValue ?X] <-
                              ?T memberOf time and
                              ?X = ?T.secondOfMinute + (?T.minuteOfHour*60) + (?T.hourOfDay*60*60).

            axiom secondsBetweenTimes
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "the difference in seconds between 2 times"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        secondsBetween[instant1 hasValue ?T1, instant2 hasValue T2, result hasValue ?X] <-
                              ?T1 memberOf time and ?T2 memberOf time and
                              ?X = secondsFromMidnight(?T1) - secondsFromMidnight(?T2).

            axiom equalityDateAndTime
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "computes if Date and Time are equal"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        ?X = ?Y <-
                              ?X memberOf dateAndTime and ?Y memberOf dateAndTime and
                              ?X.date = ?Y.date and
                              ?X.time = ?Y.time.

            axiom beforeDateAndTime
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "computes if a given date and time ?X is before another date and time ?Y"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        ?X < ?Y <-
                              ?X memberOf dateAndTime and ?Y memberOf dateAndTime and
                              ((?X.date = ?Y.date and ?X.time < ?Y.time) or
                              ?X.date < ?Y.date).

            axiom afterDateAndTime
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "defined as inverse of beforeDateAndTime"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        ?X > ?Y <- ?X
                              memberOf dateAndTime and ?Y memberOf dateAndTime and
                              ?Y < ?X.

            axiom secondsBetweenDateAndTime
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "computes the difference in seconds between two different DateAndTime"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        secondsBetween[instant1 hasValue ?D1, instant2 hasValue ?D2, result hasValue ?X] <-
                              ?D1 memberOf dateAndTime and ?D2 memberOf dateAndTime and
                              ?X = secondsFromMidnight(?D1.time) + julianDayNumber(?D1.date) * 24 * 60 * 60 -
                                          (secondsFromMidnight(?D2.time) + julianDayNumber(?D2.date) * 24 * 60 * 60).

            axiom daysBetweenDateAndTime
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "the difference in days between two different DateAndTime"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        daysBetween[instant1 hasValue ?T1, instant2 hasValue T2, result hasValue ?X] <-
                              D1 memberOf dateAndTime and D2 memberOf dateAndTime and
                              ?X = daysBetween(D1.date, D2.date).

            axiom intervalContainment
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "computes if a interval ?X contains a second interval ?Y"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        contains(?X, ?Y) <-
                              ?X memberOf interval and ?Y memberOf interval and
                              (?X.start < ?Y.start or ?X.start = ?Y.start) and
                              (?X.end > ?Y.end or ?X.end = ?Y.end).

            axiom instantContainment
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "computes if a interval ?X contains a instant ?Y"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                        contains(?X, ?Y) <-
                              ?X memberOf interval and ?Y memberOf instant and
                              (?X.start < ?Y or ?X.start = ?Y) and
                              (?X.end > ?Y or ?X.end = ?Y).

3.1.3 Purchase Ontology

The Purchase Ontology describes the domain of purchasing within a B2C scenario. In order to base this ontology on existing, commonly accepted conceptual models for purchasing, RosettaNet's PIP3A4 "PurchaseOrderRequest" [RosettaNet] has been transformed into a WSMO ontology. However, RosettaNet as well as the other existing conceptual models for purchasing like ebXML [ebXML] and EDIFACT [EDIFACT] are designed for B2B purchase scenarios and thus not applicable for B2C settings as the one of this use case. Because of this, the Purchase Ontology defined in the folloing listing describes ontological notions relevant for purchasing within a B2C setting. We refer to the WSML representation of RosettaNet's PIP3A4 "PurchaseOrderRequest" which is provided in listing B5, Appendix B, denoting the realted concepts within the realtion attribute of the non functional properties.

The main constructs of the Purchase Ontology are :

Listing 3. Domain Ontology “Purchase”
namespace <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/purchase#>>
            dc:<<http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1#>>
            cu:<<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.2/v0.1/20040628/resources/owlCurrencyMediator.wsml#>>
            dt:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/dateTime#>>
            loc:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location#>>
            prs:<<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/owlPersonMediator.wsml>>
            rn:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet#>>
            xsd:<<http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#>>
            targetnamespace: <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/purchase#>>

ontology <<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/purchase/>>

      nonFunctionalProperties
            dc:title hasValue "B2C Purchase Ontology"
            dc:creator hasValue "DERI International"
            dc:subject hasValues {"Purchase", "Purchase Order", "Buyer", "Seller", "Product", "Price", "Payment method", "Delivery"}
            dc:description hasValue "general ontology for purchasing in B2C settings, related to 3A4 PIP of RosettaNet"
            dc:publisher hasValue "DERI International"
            dc:contributor hasValues {<<http://sw.deri.ie/~haller/foaf.rdf>>, "Michael Stollberg"}
            dc:date hasValue "2004-10-27"
            dc:type hasValue <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d2/#ontologies>>
            dc:format hasValue "text/html"
            dc:language hasValue "en-US"
            dc:relation hasValues {<<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet/>>, 
                  <<http://www.daml.ecs.soton.ac.uk/ont/currency.daml>>, 
                  <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/dateTime>>,
                  <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location>>}
            dc:rights hasValue <<http://www.deri.org/privacy.html>>
            version hasValue "$Revision: 1.7 $"
      endNonFunctionalProperties


      importedOntologies {<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/dateTime.wsml>>,
            <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location.wsml>>}

      usedMediators 
            ooMediator {<<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/owlCurrencyMediator.wsml>>,
                                                <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/owlPersonMediator.wsml>>}

/*
 * Purchase, Purchase Order            
*/ 
            concept purchase
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "a purchase for a product between a buyer & a seller"
                        dc:relation hasValues {<<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet#pip3A4Purchase>>} 
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  purchaseIdentifier ofType identifier
                  purchaseorder ofType purchaseOrder
                  buyer ofType buyer
                  seller ofType seller
                  
            concept identifier subConceptOf xsd:string
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "Unique identifier for a thing, 
                               i.e. a numeric value or alphanumeric value"
                        dc:relation hasValues {<<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet#proprietaryDocumentIdentifier>>}
                  endNonFunctionalProperties                  

            concept purchaseOrder
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "The collection of business properties that
                               describes the product, payment, and delivery terms of a purchase"
                        dc:relation hasValues {<<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet#purchaseOrder>>}
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  product ofType set product 
                  payment ofType paymentMethod 
                  delivery ofType delivery 
                  contractDate ofType dt:date
                  paymentTerms ofType paymentTerms
                  totalPrice ofType financialAount 
                  
                  
/*
 * Purchase Partners 
*/ 
            concept buyer
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "the partner that buys a product in a purchase"
                        dc:relation hasValues {<<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet#buyer>>}
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  contactInformation ofType contactInformation
                  billToAddress ofType loc:address 
                  shipToAddress ofType loc:address 
                  hasPayment ofType set paymentMethod

            concept seller
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "the partner that sells a product in a purchase"
                        dc:relation hasValues {<<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet#seller>>}
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  contactInformation ofType contactInformation
                  acceptsPaymentMethod ofType set paymentMethod

            concept contactInformation
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "The collection of business properties that
                               provide communication and address information for
                               contacting a person, organization or business."
                        dc:relation hasValues {<<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet#contactInformation>>}
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  name ofType xsd:string
                  emailaddress ofType xsd:string
                  faxnumber ofType xsd:string
                  telephonenumber ofType xsd:string
                  physicalAddress ofType loc:address

/* 
 * Product 
*/ 

            concept product
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "The collection of business properties that
                               describes a product."
                        dc:relation hasValues {<<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet#productLineItem>>}
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  productidentification ofType productIdentification
                  item ofType set productItem 
                  provider ofType seller 
                  price ofType financialAmount 
                  
            concept productItem
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "a placeholder for an item that is provided for sale by a
                               seller. Any concept can be declared as a subconcept of productItem"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                              
             concept financialAmount
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "The collection of business properties
                               that describe the monetary amount defined by a specified currency."
                        dc:relation hasValues {<<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet#financialAmount>>}
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  monetaryamount ofType xsd:float
                  globalcurrencycode ofType cu:currency
                  invoicechargetypecode ofType xsd:string
                        nonFunctionalProperties
                              dc:description hasValue "Code identifying the values for the types of charges contained in an invoice."
                        endNonFunctionalProperties             


/* 
 * Payment Methods 
 */ 
 
             concept paymentMethod
                   nonFunctionalProperties
                         dc:description hasValue "superconcept of payment methods"
                   endNonFunctionalProperties

             concept creditCard subConceptOf paymentMethod
                   nonFunctionalProperties
                         dc:description hasValue "payment method credit card"
                   endNonFunctionalProperties
                   type ofType creditCardType 
                   creditCardNumber ofType xsd:integer
                   holder ofType xsd:string
                   expMonth ofType dt:monthOfYear
                   expYear ofType dt:year      

             concept creditCardType 
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "specifies type of credit card. This is a unique code 
                              defined by the first 4 digits of the credit card number; 
                              thus, we we would have the knowledge for decoding these digits, the 
                              credit card type could be inferred from the credit card number."
                  endNonFunctionalProperties


             concept invoice subConceptOf paymentMethod
                   nonFunctionalProperties
                         dc:description hasValue "payment method invoice"
                   endNonFunctionalProperties
                   invoiceNumber ofType xsd:string
                   payer ofType buyer
                   receiver ofType seller
                   receiverAccount ofType account 

             concept check subConceptOf paymentMethod
                   nonFunctionalProperties
                         dc:description hasValue "payment method check"
                   endNonFunctionalProperties
                   checkNumber ofType xsd:integer 
                   drawer ofType buyer 
                   receiver ofType seller
                   drawerAccount ofType account 

             concept cash subConceptOf paymentMethod
                   nonFunctionalProperties
                         dc:description hasValue "payment method cash"
                   endNonFunctionalProperties
                   payer ofType buyer 
                   receiver ofType seller 


            concept account
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "The collection of business properties that
                               describe a bank account."
                        dc:relation hasValues {<<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet#accountDescription>>}                        
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  accountnumber ofType xsd:string
                  holder ofType prs:person 
                  provider ofType financialInstitute 
                  globalaccountclassificationcode ofType xsd:string
                        nonFunctionalProperties
                              dc:description hasValue "Account classification indicating
                                     its functionality, e.g., credit card or a giro account."
                        endNonFunctionalProperties

            concept financialInstitute
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "an organization that provides financial services."
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  name ofType xsd:string
                  contactInformation ofType contactInformation 

            concept bank subConceptOf financialInstitute
             nonFunctionalProperties
                   dc:description hasValue "specifies a bank (financial institute)"
             endNonFunctionalProperties
             bankIdentifierCode ofType xsd:string
                        nonFunctionalProperties
                              dc:description hasValue "the (inter)national code of the bank"
                        endNonFunctionalProperties


/* 
 * Payment Terms 
 */ 

            concept paymentTerms
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "The collection of business properties that describe payment terms."
                        dc:relation hasValues {<<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet#paymentTerms>>}                        
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  discounts ofType discounts
                  globalpaymentconditioncode ofType xsd:string
                        nonFunctionalProperties
                              dc:description hasValue "A code identifying the conditions
                                     under which payment will be made."
                        endNonFunctionalProperties
                  nettermsday ofType dt:dayOfMonth
                        nonFunctionalProperties
                              dc:description hasValue "The specific day of the month
                                     a payment is due without incurring late charges."
                        endNonFunctionalProperties
                  nettermsdays ofType dt:interval
                        nonFunctionalProperties
                         dc:description hasValue "The number of days within
                                    which a payment is due without incurring late charges."
                        endNonFunctionalProperties
                  percentdue ofType xsd:float
                        nonFunctionalProperties
                              dc:description hasValue "The amount owed expressed as a percentage."
                        endNonFunctionalProperties
                  
            concept discounts
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "The collection of business properties that describe payment discounts."
                        dc:relation hasValues {<<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet#discounts>>}                        
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  discountday ofType dt:dayOfMonth
                        nonFunctionalProperties
                              dc:description hasValue "The specific day of the month a
                                     payment is required in order to receive a discount."
                        endNonFunctionalProperties
                  discountdays ofType dt:interval
                        nonFunctionalProperties
                              dc:description hasValue "The number of days within which a
                                     payment is required in order to receive a discount."
                        endNonFunctionalProperties
                  discountpercent ofType xsd:float
                        nonFunctionalProperties
                              dc:description hasValue "The financial percent representing a reduction to the total amount due."
                        endNonFunctionalProperties

/*
 * Delivery 
*/ 

             concept delivery
                   nonFunctionalProperties
                         dc:description hasValue "superconcept of delivery methods. one instance of a            
                               delivery is a main function of the marketplace in addition to purchase contracting."
                   endNonFunctionalProperties
                   deliveryItem ofType set product
                   sender ofType seller 
                   receiver ofType buyer 

             concept dropShip subConceptOf delivery
                   nonFunctionalProperties
                         dc:description hasValue "delivery directly to the buyer shipping address by a delivery service"
                         dc:relation hasValues {<<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet#isDropShip>>}                        
                   endNonFunctionalProperties
                   carrier ofType dropShipCarrier
      
             concept dropShipCarrier 
                   nonFunctionalProperties
                         dc:description hasValue "a company that provides a drop ship delivery service"
                         dc:relation hasValues {<<http://wsmo.org/ontologies/rosettanet#carrierInformation>>}                        
                   endNonFunctionalProperties
                   contactInformation ofType contactInformation
                   businessIdentifier ofType rn:globalBusinessIdentifier 
                   transportBy ofType transportationMean
                   deliveryCoverage ofType loc:location 

             concept transportationMean 
                   nonFunctionalProperties
                         dc:description hasValue "mean of transportation used by a drop ship delivery service"
                   endNonFunctionalProperties
            
      
             concept selfCollection subConceptOf delivery
                   nonFunctionalProperties
                         dc:description hasValue "buyer collects purchased "
                   endNonFunctionalProperties
             
             concept onlineDelivery subConceptOf delivery
                   nonFunctionalProperties
                         dc:description hasValue "a product is delivery online as a piece of information"
                   endNonFunctionalProperties
                   onlineDeliveryMethod ofType xsd:string 

3.1.4 Location Ontology

The "Location Ontology" defines concepts for locations, including cities and states, as well as postal addresses. This ontology is based on the DAML ontology for geographical locations (Appendix B5), an ontology describing a wide variety of locations and geographical areas. The concept country is extended using the OWL-Factbook ontology (Appendix B2). The concept address reuses the DAML address ontology (Appendix B3).

Listing 4. Domain Ontology “Locations”
namespace <<http:://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location#>>
      dc:<<http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1#>>
      wsml:<<http://www.wsmo.org/d2/#>>
      cnt:<<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/owlFactbookMediator.wsml#>>
      geo:<<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/owlGeoMediator.wsml#>>
      ad:<<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/owlAddressMediator.wsml#>>
      xsd:<<http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#>>

ontology <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location>>

      nonFunctionalProperties 
            dc:title hasValue "Locations Ontology"
            dc:creator hasValue "DERI International"
            dc:subject hasValues {"Location", "Country", "State", "City", "Address"}
            dc:description hasValue "Ontology for representing locations in the current political/social system"
            dc:publisher hasValue "DERI International"
            dc:contributor hasValues {<<http://www.deri.org/foaf#lara>>,
                  <<http://homepage.uibk.ac.at/~c703262/foaf.rdf>>}
            dc:date hasValue "2004-10-04"
            dc:type hasValue <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d2#ontologies>>
            dc:format hasValue "text/html"
            dc:language hasValue "en-US"
            dc:identifier hasValue <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location>>
            dc:source hasValue <<http://www.daml.org/2001/02/geofile/geofile-ont>>
            dc:language hasValue "en-US"
            dc:relation hasValues {<<http://www.daml.org/2001/09/countries/fips-10-4-ont>>,
                  <<http://www.daml.org/2001/09/countries/iso-3166-ont>>,
                  <<http://www.daml.org/2003/09/factbook/factbook-ont>>,
                  <<http://www.daml.org/2001/02/geofile/geofile-ont>>,
                  <<http://daml.umbc.edu/ontologies/ittalks/address>>}
            dc:coverage hasValue "ID:7029392 Name:World"
            dc:rights hasValue <<http://www.deri.org/privacy.html>>
            version hasValue "$Revision: 1.3 $"
      endNonFunctionalProperties 
      
      usedMediators {<<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/owlFactbookMediator.wsml>>,
            <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/owlAddressMediator.wsml>>,
            <<http://www.daml.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/owlGeoMediator.wsml>>}
            
      concept country subConceptOf {cnt:country, geo:country}
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "Add the codes to the CIA country properties"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            fipsCode ofType xsd:string
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "FIPS 10-4 Country Code"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            isoCode ofType xsd:string
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "ISO 3166 Country Code"
            endNonFunctionalProperties

      concept address subConceptOf ad:address
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "Extended address, adding more details to
                        city, state and country"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            city ofType city
            state ofType state
            country ofType country
            
      concept city subConceptOf geo:city
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "City"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            population ofType xsd:integer
            extension ofType xsd:integer
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "Extension of the city in square kilometers"
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
            zipcodes ofType set xsd:string
      
      concept state subConceptOf geo:state
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "State"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            cities ofType set city
            population ofType xsd:integer
            extension ofType xsd:integer
             
      concept border subConceptOf geo:geographicLocation
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "Border between two countries. Notice that it
                        would be more natural to model this as a location with a cardinality
                        constraint = 2 for the country property. However, it is not clear
                        how to do this in F-Logic"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            countryA ofType country
            countryB ofType country            

      concept distance
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "Distance between two points"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            amount ofType xsd:float 
            units ofType xsd:string

      axiom validDistance
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "The amount in a distance cannot be less than 0.
                        We only accept kilometers and miles."
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            definedBy
                  constraint
                        ?D[
                              amount hasValue ?A,
                              units hasValue ?U
                        ]memberOf distance
                        and ?A < 0
                        and not (U="Kilometers" or U="Miles").

      function kilometers
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "Calculates a distance in kilometers"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            d ofType distance
            range ofType xsd:float
            definedBy
                  forAll ?x,?y (      kilometers[d hasValue ?d, result hasValue ?y] equivalent
                         ?d[
                                    amount hasValue ?a,
                                    units hasValue ?u
                         ] and 
                              ( (?u="Kilometers" and ?y=?a) or
                                    (?a="Miles" and ?y=?a*1.609344))).

      function miles
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "Calculates a distance in miles"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            d ofType distance
            range ofType xsd:float
            definedBy
                  forAll ?x,?y (      miles[d hasValue ?d, result hasValue ?y] equivalent
                         ?d[
                                    amount hasValue ?a,
                                    units hasValue ?u
                         ] and 
                              ( (?u="Miles" and ?y=?a) or
                                    (?a="Kilometers" and ?y=?a/1.609344))).

      relation equalDistance
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "Computes equality of a distance"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            d1 ofType distance
            d2 ofType distance
            definedBy
                  forAll ?x,?y ( equalDistance[d1 hasValue ?x, d2 hasValue ?y] equivalent
                                                 kilometers(?x,?k1) and kilometers(?y,?k2) and ?k1=?k2).


      relation lessThanDistance
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "Computes -less than- for a distance"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            d1 ofType distance
            d2 ofType distance
            definedBy
                  forAll ?x,?y ( equalDistance[d1 hasValue ?x, d2 hasValue ?y] equivalent
                                                 kilometers(?x,?k1) and kilometers(?y,?k2) and ?k1<?k2).
            
      relation moreThanDistance
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "Computes -more than- for a distance"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            d1 ofType distance
            d2 ofType distance
            definedBy
                  forAll ?x,?y ( equalDistance[d1 hasValue ?x, d2 hasValue ?y] equivalent
                                                 kilometers(?x,?k1) and kilometers(?y,?k2) and ?k1>?k2).

3.1.5 VTA Use Case Knowledge Base

The VTA Use Case Knowledge Base holds all instance data that are needed within the use case descriptions. The knowledge base is defined as an WSMO ontology that holds instances of all four domain ontologies defined above. Within this knowlegde base, only a selection of instances is defined that is used within the subsequent WSMO component models.

Listing 5. VTA Use Case Knowledge Base
/**
 * VTA Use Case Knowledge Base
 * this is a collection of pre-defined data for the WSMO D3.3 VTA Use Case
*/

namespace <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/kb.wsml#>>
      dc:<<http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1#>>
      wsml:<<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d16/d16.1/v0.2/20040418#>>
      tc:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/trainConnection#>>
      dt:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/dateTime#>>
      tc:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/trainConnection#>>
      po:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/purchase#>>
      cu:<<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.2/v0.1/20040628/resources/owlCurrencyMediator.wsml#>>
      loc:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location#>>

ontology <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/kb.wsml>>

nonFunctionalProperties
      dc:title hasValue "VTA Use Case Knowledge Base"
      dc:creator hasValue "SWF Project"
      dc:subject hasValues {dt:dateandtime, po:paymentMethods, loc:location}
      dc:description hasValue "describes pre-defined instance data for the VTA Use Case"
      dc:publisher hasValue "SWF Project"
      dc:contributor hasValue "Michael Stollberg, Holger Lausen, Ruben Lara, Axel Polleres, Armin Haller"
      dc:date hasValue "2004-10-27"
      dc:type hasValue <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d2/#ontologies>>
      dc:format hasValue "text/html"
      dc:language hasValue "en-US"
      dc:relation hasValues {<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/dateTime>>,
                  <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/trainConnection>>,
                  <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/purchase>>,
                  <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location>>}
      dc:coverage hasValue "VTA virtual marketplace"
      dc:rights hasValue <<http://www.deri.org/privacy.html>>
      version hasValue "$Revision: 1.2 $"
endNonFunctionalProperties

importedOntologies {<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/dateTime>>,
                  <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/trainConnection>>,
                  <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/purchase>>,
                  <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location>>}

      usedMediators ooMediator <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/owlCurrencyMediator.wsml>>
      
      
// Station instances

      instance innsbruckHbf memberOf station
            nonFunctionalProperties
                  dc:description hasValue "Innsbruck central station"
            endNonFunctionalProperties
            name hasValue "Innsbruck Hbf"^^xsd:string
            code hasValue "INN"^^xsd:string
            locatedIn hasValues {loc:innsbruck}
            
      instance frankfurtHbf memberOf station
            name hasValue "Frankfurt Hbf"^^xsd:string
            code hasValue "FKF"^^xsd:string
            locatedIn hasValues {loc:frankfurt}

// Date and Time Instance 

comment: the current date is defined as an instance here, as there is no build in function avaliable for this at the moment. 

      instance currentDate memberOf dt:dateandtime 
            date hasValue currentDateDate      
            time hasValue currentDateTime      

      instance currentDateDate memberOf dt:date
             dayOfMonth hasValue 22
             monthOfYear hasValue 5
             year hasValue 2004

      instance currentDateTime memberOf dt:time 
             hourOfDay hasValue 15
             minuteOfHour hasValue 27
             secondOfMinute hasValue 38


// Locations
      instance europe memberOf loc:continent
            name hasValue "Europe"


      instance austria memberOf country
            fipsCode hasValue "AU"^^xsd:string
            isoCode hasValue "AT"^^xsd:string
                  
      instance germany memberOf country
            fipsCode hasValue "GM"^^xsd:string
            isoCode hasValue "DE"^^xsd:string
                  
      instance usa memberOf country
            fipsCode hasValue "US"^^xsd:string
            isoCode hasValue "US"^^xsd:string                  
                  
            
      instance massachusetts memberOf state
            name hasValue "Massachusetts"^^xsd:string
            locatedIn hasValue usa


      instance innsbruck memberOf city
            name hasValue "Innsbruck"^^xsd:string
            locatedIn hasValue austria
      
      instance frankfurt memberOf city
            name hasValue "Frankfurt"^^xsd:string
            locatedIn hasValue germany
                              
      instance boston memberOf city
            name hasValue "Boston"^^xsd:string
            locatedIn hasValue usa
            


/*
 * Drop Ship Deliverers      
 */
instance PostAt http://www.post.at/ memberOf po:dropShipCarrier
                  name hasValue "Oesterreichische Post AG"
                  companyNumber hasValue "post"
                  contactaddress hasValue PostATAddress
                  transportBy hasValue truck
                  deliveryCoverage hasValue europe

instance PostATAddress memberOf loc:address
                  street hasValue "Südtiroler Platz"
                  number hasValue "5-7 "
                  city hasValue innsbruck
                  zip hasValue 6020


// transportation means 

instance truck memberOf po:transportationMean 

instance train memberOf po:transportationMean 

instance plane memberOf po:transportationMean 

/*
 * currencies - only Euro, as the markeptlace is limited to Austria
 */
instance euro memberOf cu:curreny
 name hasValue "Euro"
 code hasValue "EUR" 

/*
 * payment methods 
 */
instance masterCard memberOf po:creditCardType

instance visa memberOf po:creditCardType

instance amercianExpress memberOf po:creditCardType

3.2. Goals

Goals denote what a user wants as the result of the Web Service. For modeling the goal, WSMO describes the information elements that the user wants to get from the service (the postcondition) together with the state of the world desired after the service execution (the effect).

In WSMO, Goals can be defined a different levels of granularity. By so-called GG Mediators, new, more specific Goals can be created out of generic existing Goals. You can also think of generic Goals as being pre-defined in a specific application context, wherefrom concrete Goals can be generated from. In order to showcase this, we define a generic Goal for buying a ticket for any kind of trip (Listing 6), a concrete Goal wherein a user wants to buy a train itinerary from Innsbruck to Frankfurt on a certain date (Listing 7), and a GG Mediator that connects the generic Goal to tickets for traintrips within Austria and Germany (see Section 3.4.3. for the GG Mediator that connects this two Goals).

Listing 6 shows the generic Goal with the following description elements:

Listing 6: Goal - buying a ticket online
namespace <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041119/resources/GeneralTrainTrip#>>
      dc:<<http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1#>>
      tc:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/trainConnection#>>
      po:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/purchase#>>
      loc:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location#>>

goal <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041119/resources/goal1.wsml>>

      nonFunctionalProperties 
            dc:title hasValue "Buying a ticket online"
            dc:creator hasValue "DERI International"
            dc:subject hasValues {"Tickets", "Online Ticket Booking", "trip"}
            dc:description hasValue "Express the goal of buying a ticket for a trip"
            dc:publisher hasValue "DERI International"
            dc:contributor hasValues {"Michael Stollberg",
                  <<http://www.deri.org/foaf#lara>>,
                  <<http://homepage.uibk.ac.at/~c703240/foaf.rdf>>,
                  <<http://homepage.uibk.ac.at/~c703262/foaf.rdf>>}
            dc:date hasValue "2004-10-04"
            dc:type hasValue <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d2#goals>>
            dc:format hasValue "text/html"
            dc:identifier hasValue <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041119/resources/goal1.wsml>>
            dc:language hasValue "en-US"
            dc:relation hasValues {<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/trainConnection>>,
                  <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/purchase>>,
                  <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location>>}
            dc:coverage hasValue "ID:7029392 Name:World"
            dc:rights hasValue <<http://deri.at/privacy.html>>
            version hasValue "$Revision: 1.4 $"
      endNonFunctionalProperties

      importedOntologies {<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/trainConnection>>,
            <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/purchase>>,
            <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location>>}
 
      postcondition 
            axiom purchasingTicketForTrip
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "This goal expresses the general desire of buying a ticket for 
                        any kind of itinerary."
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                   exists ?Purchase, ?Purchaseorder, ?Buyer, ?Product, ?PaymentMethod, ?Ticket, ?Itinerary, ?Passenger, ?Trip
                   (?Purchase memberOf po:purchase[
                         po:purchaseorder hasValue ?Purchaseorder,
                         po:buyer hasValue ?Buyer
                   ] and 
                   ?Buyer memberOf po:buyer and 
                   ?Purchaseorder memberOf po:purchaseOrder[
                         po:product hasValues {?Product},      
                         po:payment hasValue ?PaymentMethod
                   ] and 
                   ?PaymentMethod memberOf po:paymentMethod and 
                   ?Product memberOf po:product[
                         po:item hasValues {?Ticket}
                   ] and 
                   ?Ticket memberOf tc:ticket[
                         po:itinerary hasValue ?Itinerary
                   ] and 
                   ?Itinerary memberOf tc:itinerary[
                         po:passenger hasValue ?Passenger,
                         po:trip hasValue ?Trip
                   ] and 
                   ?Passenger memberOf tc:person and 
                   ?Trip memberOf tc:trip) . 
 
 
       effect 
            axiom havingTradeForTrip
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "The goal effect is to get the purchased ticket delivered 
                              to the buyer."
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                   exists ?Delivery, ?Product, ?Buyer, ?Ticket
                   (
                   ?Delivery memberOf po:delivery[
                              po:deliveryItem hasValues {?Product}, 
                              po:receiver hasValue ?Buyer 
                   ] and 
                   ?Product memberOf po:product[
                         po:item hasValues {?Ticket}
                   ] and 
                   ?Buyer memberOf po:buyer and 
                   ?Ticket memberOf tc:ticket
                   ) .

The concrete Goal expresses the desire to buy a train ticket by refining the notions of the general Goal. Listing 7 shows this Goal with the following elements:

Listing 7: Goal - buying a train ticket from Innsbruck to Frankfurt online
namespace <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041119/resources/SpecificTrainTripInnbsruckFrankfurt#>>
            dc:<<http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1#>>
            dt:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/dateTime#>>
            tc:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/trainConnection#>>
            po:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/purchase#>>
            loc:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location#>>
            kb:<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/kb#>>
            wsml:<<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d2/#>>
            xsd:<<http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#>>

goal <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041119/resources/goal.wsml>>

      nonFunctionalProperties
            dc:title hasValue "Buying a train ticket from Innsbruck to Frankfurt on..."
            dc:creator hasValue "DERI International"
            dc:subject hasValues {"Train Tickets", "Online Ticket Booking", "Train trip"}
            dc:description hasValue "Express the goal of buying a concrete ticket for a train trip"
            dc:publisher hasValue "DERI International"
            dc:contributor hasValues{"Michael Stollberg",
                  <<http://www.deri.org/foaf#lara>>,
                  <<http://homepage.uibk.ac.at/~c703240/foaf.rdf>>,
                  <<http://homepage.uibk.ac.at/~c703262/foaf.rdf>>,
                  <<http://www.deri.org/foaf#haller>>}
            dc:date hasValue "2004-10-04"
            dc:type hasValue <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d2#goals>>
            dc:format hasValue "text/html"
            dc:identifier hasValue <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041008/resources/goal.wsml>>
            dc:language hasValue "en-US"
            dc:relation hasValues {<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/dateTime>>,
                  <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/trainConnection>>,
                  <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/purchase>>,
                  <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/location>>}
            dc:coverage hasValue "ID:7029392 Name:World"
            dc:rights hasValue <<http://deri.at/privacy.html>>
            version hasValue "$Revision: 1.4 $"
      endNonFunctionalProperties


      // all mediators and ontologies are inherited from the GG Mediator 

      usedMediators 
            ggMediator <<http://www.wsmo.org/2004/d3/d3.3/v0.1/20041105/resources/ggm1.wsml>>

      importedOntologies {<<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/dateTime>>, <<http://www.wsmo.org/ontologies/kb>>}


      // the constants defined in the logical expressions refer to instances defined in the VTA Use Case Knowledge Base      
      
      postcondition 
            axiom purchasingTicketForSpecificTraintrip
                  nonFunctionalProperties
                        dc:description hasValue "The goal postcondition specifies that Tim Berners-Lee wants 
                              to go buy a train ticket from Innsbruck to Frankfurt, departing from innsbruckHbf 
                              on 17th July 2004 at 6 p.m."
                  endNonFunctionalProperties
                  definedBy
                   exists ?Purchase, ?Purchaseorder, ?Buyer, ?Product, ?PaymentMethod, ?Ticket, ?Itinerary, ?Passenger, ?Trip,
                                          ?DepartureTime, ?DepartureDate, ?Departure, ?TBLAddress, ?TBLContactInformation
                   (
                   ?Purchase memberOf po:purchase[
                         po:purchaseorder hasValue ?Purchaseorder,
                         po:buyer hasValue ?Buyer
                   ] and 
                   ?Buyer memberOf po:buyer[
                         po:contactInformation hasValue ?TBLContactInformation,
                         po:billToAddress hasValue ?TBLAddress,
                         po:hasPayment hasValues {?PaymentMethod}                  
                   ] and 
                   ?TBLContactInformation memberOf po:contactInformation[
                              po:name hasValue "Tim Berners-Lee",
                              po:emailaddress hasValue "tbl@w3c.org"
                   ] and 
                   ?TBLAddress memberOf loc:address[
                         po:streetAddress hasValue "32 Vassar Street",
                         po:city hasValue boston,
                         po:state hasValue massachusetts, 
                         po:country hasValue usa
                   ] and
                   ?Purchaseorder memberOf po:purchaseOrder[
                         po:product hasValues {?Product},      
                         po:payment hasValue ?PaymentMethod
                   ] and 
                   ?PaymentMethod memberOf po:creditCard[
                         po:type hasValue masterCard,      
                         po:creditCardNumber hasValue 5535446466867747,
                         po:holder hasValue "Tim Berners-Lee",
                         po:expMonth hasValue 09,
                         po:expYear hasValue 2007                  
                   ] and 
                   ?Product memberOf po:product[
                         po:item hasValues